Systemic reactions from allergy skin testing: 0.4% for skin prick testing, 3.2% for intradermal

Skin testing is the diagnostic cornerstone for allergies and is considered extremely safe, carrying only a small risk of systemic reactions.

A prospective study included 1,500 patients at the University of South Florida and aimed to determine the 12-month incidence of systemic reactions (SRs) to skin prick testing (SPT) and intradermal skin testing (ST). Epinephrine (0.2 mL of a 1:1,000 dilution) was administered intramuscularly in the deltoid as soon as any remote signs or symptoms occurred.

A wheal with multiple pseudopods and a satellite lesion in the upper left. Image source: Modified from Sakurako Kitsa's photostream, Flickr (used with the author's permission).

Four percent (3.6%) of patients had systemic reactions:

- 6 with skin prick testing (SPT), 0.4% of patients, 1 for every 240 patients tested
- 46 with intradermal testing

83% of patients with reactions were female, and 33% had asthma.

Systemic symptoms included:

- pruritic eyes, nose, or pharynx
- worsening cough
- sensation of difficulty swallowing
- worsening nasal congestion
- rhinorrhea
- chest tightness or shortness of breath
- generalized pruritus
- sneezing
- wheeze
- urticaria

No severe asthma, shock, hypotension, unconsciousness, or biphasic reactions occurred.

Treatment of reactions

100% of patients received epinephrine intramuscularly, 92% received oral prednisone, 7% oral prednisone to take 6 to 8 hours after a reaction, 96% oral antihistamine, and 12% nebulized albuterol.

Among patients who had allergy skin testing, systemic reactions occurred in:

- 0.4% for skin prick testing (SPT), 1 for every 240 patients tested
- 3.2% for intradermal testing

An older study (1993) showed that the probability of inducing systemic allergic reactions by skin testing was less than 0.02%. This probability has increased 20 times as of year 2009, to 0.4%.

100% of patients quickly responded to epinephrine intramuscularly (IM) in the deltoid. This immediate administration of epinephrine seems to prevent more serious and biphasic reactions.

Patients that should be considered at higher risk of systemic/anaphylactic reactions:

- women
- history of previous anaphylactic reactions
- small children
- pregnant women
- uncontrolled asthma
- high degree of reactivity

If your clinic sees 5-6 new patients per day and all of them undergo skin testing, you could expect one systemic reaction every 10 weeks, so be prepared.

The current allergy skin tests are virtually painless. This video by Dr. Bassett, a board-certified allergist from New York City, shows what to expect when visiting an allergy clinic for diagnosis and treatment:

From ACAAI online allergy lectures (COLA): This is a documentary about a workshop designed to teach and assess the ability of allergy/Immunology fellows to perform allergy skin tests. Held on April 20, 2012:

Number of intradermal skin tests for adult? AAAAI: For many 12. For some, 70 SPT and 40 intracutaneous tests

Comments from Twitter:

David Fischer, MD @IgECPD4: What is the relative safety of doing skin prick testing in patients on beta-blockers? Pretty good from this study

@Allergy: Skin prick testing on BB safe in 199 patients - However, Incidence of systemic reactions is 1:250 with SPT

David Fischer, MD @IgECPD4: 1:250 if looking at which population: venom/penicillin or inhalant/food? Inhalant/food much lower: Euro review

David Fischer, MD @IgECPD4: Lockey's data recent but much higher/worse than other references in blog post. Lin (3rd) article quotes 0.02% risk with 14 yrs and 10K pt.

@Allergy: There are regional differences, e.g. number of skin tests per visit in the U.S., multisensitized vs. monsensitized patients.

David Fischer, MD @IgECPD4: Really depends on severity of pt population, venom/penicillin vs food/inhalant, no of tests picked and methods/doses picked 4 tests.

1 comment:

  1. Anonymous12/05/2012

    @PhilAllergie : I agree with David Fischer : in Bordeaux, France, no systemic reaction at all for 15 years of practice in more than (let me estimate) : 180.000 skin prick testing.

    The only systemic reaction we had were with IDR (once in 15 years) or allergy shots (One each 5 years).